Rule of Law-Not Rule of Man

By Francisco Gonzalez, JMI Development Director
Following from my previous blog post, “Libertarianism: 2010″, Cato Institute Senior fellow Ilya Shapiro also spoke heavily about the libertarian principle of the rule of law, during his lecture at FSU’s law school on February 3. He gave an account of common law and the principles of contract, tort, and property. Shapiro also stressed that libertarians believe in the rule of law, not the rule of man.

Leaning on the articulations by both F.A. Hayek and James Madison, Shapiro stressed that libertarians believe that guided by this philosophy, laws should be (1) general and abstract – and not command certain actions, (2) known and certain, so individuals will know how they can participate in society peacefully and legally and plan their own actions, and (3) apply equally to all persons.

Laws must also have a legitimate authority – that is why we consent to the law. And, individual and minority rights must be observed. The Constitution is based on these standards and that is what helps make it legitimate and the supreme law of the land. Shapiro proclaimed that “The Constitution may be the most libertarian document ever put into law.” It offers and across the board protection of liberty. Yet, he also admitted that liberty is under great threat, given the way we and our elected officials treat the Constitution today.

Leave a Comment

Responses to “Rule of Law-Not Rule of Man”:

  1. Kendelyn says:

    I worry about one of Shapiro’s points. General and abstract laws allow for broad interpretation and could be manipulated to fit a prosecuter’s interests. On the other hand, broad laws mean fewer laws, and people would be more likely to know what laws exist and how they apply. I’m not sure I completely agree with Shapiro’s take on libertarianism..

  2. [...] America is a nation founded on the Rule of Law not the Rule of Men. [...]

  3. The tool features a feature which automatically detects spam, of course,
    if the content sent is recognized as to be spam, it’s going straight for your spam folder.
    In July 2008, the Seagate Barracuda hard disk drive released
    the greatest, Barracuda 7200. Rkill might be found at:
    Once downloaded and run, rkill stops any background processes
    that are suspicious for any period of about a couple of minutes depending on what type
    of process it is.

  4. [...] These two sentiments – the first attributable most probably to Richard Henry Lee, one of the so-called Anti-Federalists whom we have to thank for the inclusion of the Bill of Rights into our federal Constitution, and the second to John Locke, foremost 17th century political philosopher and natural rights theorist, lay at the heart of the fundamental binary question of societal rule of law versus rule of man. [...]

  5. [...] predicted, the culture that a rule of man cultivates eventually comes home to [...]



See all sightings   events


Facebook YouTube Flickr